|
Martin Luther (1483-1546)
 But
another monk, Martin Luther, was not so intimidated and threw a new
challenge of church reform in the face of the Pope ... and his close
associate, the "Defender of the Faith" Charles V of Habsburg – the
powerful Holy Roman Emperor (and also king of the dominant political
power of the day: Spain). Such a challenge was quite daring ...
if not even suicidal.
Behind Luther's defiant spirit was a long personal pilgrimage he had
been on, one based on an deep desire to unburden himself of a profound
sense of guilt and personal condemnation before God's judgment.
For Luther, a personal breakthrough occurred as the message sank into
the head of this Augustinian professor concerning Paul's teaching
(Galatians and Romans) about divine Grace and forgiveness received
through the simple faith of the believer – and not through the demands
of any religious law or requirements of a religious system. So
"liberated" was he that he felt that his discovery had to be brought to
the world.
Luther was a teacher of the Bible to his fellow Augustinian
monks. His complete familiarity with Scripture made him aware of
and angry about the huge disparities between the way the early Church
and the contemporary Church functioned ... plus a much anticipated
visit to Rome (1510) turned into a very disillusioning experience for Luther
when he came face to face with the political intrigue and corruption
going on in the holy city.
Clearly the Church needed to clean up its act. Even Emperor
Charles knew that. The popes had become famous for their
corruption, epitomized at the beginning of the 1500s by the notorious
Borgia family ... Father Rodrigo (Pope Alexander VI – 1492-1503), his murderous
condottiero son Cesare, and his beauty-queen daughter Lucrezia – among
other illegitimate offspring ... not that a celibate pope was supposed
to have children, much less mistresses!
However, what finally sparked Luther's bold challenge to the Church was
the sale of indulgences ... to finance the building of the pope's
elaborate cathedral in Rome. This led Luther finally to post in
late October of 1517 his 95 theses on the door of the Wittenberg castle
church. It was time for the church hierarchy to answer for
its actions and behavior. It was time for the church hierarchy to
clean up its act!
This action of Luther's seemed to be the signal for a number of German
(and Scandinavian) princes to rise up in revolt against the political
status quo of old Christendom defended largely by the Pope and the Holy
Roman Emperor. In Luther they saw their chance legitimately
(i.e., on the basis of Christian morality) to break away from the
monopoly of power held by Pope and Emperor ... and develop their own
"Christian" sovereignty.1
Thus one of them, Frederick III, Elector of Saxony, took Luther under
his protection ... just as Pope Leo X (1513-1521) declared Luther a heretic (1520) and
consequently to be denied all personal support, and even to be eligible
to be killed legally by anyone who encountered him.
1Also
there was huge resentment in Germany for the heavy taxes imposed on the
Germans in support of the Roman Curia ... and especially for the
massive and very expensive cathedral being built in Rome with the goal
of restoring the majesty of the papacy.
"A Question to a Mintmaker"
(the sale of indulgences) Jörg Breu the Elder (c. 1530)

Luther posting his 95 Theses on the Wittenberg Chapel door October 31, 1517
Disputatio pro declaratione
virtutis indulgentiarum (a printed copy of Luther's 95 Theses)
– Wittenberg: Melchior Lotter
d.J., 1522
 Detail of Portrait of
Pope Leo X and Two Cardinals - by Rafael Sanzio (1518-1519)
Florence, Uffizi Gallery
Title page of Pope Leo X's
Bull, Exurge Domine, threatening to excommunicate Martin Luther (1520)
Concordia Theological
Seminary
Wartburg Castle in Eisenach
-
where Frederick III, Elector
of Saxony, hid Luther away (1521-1522)
in order to keep him from falling
in papal or imperial hands

Frederick III "The Wise" - Elector of Saxony and protector of Luther
Martin Luther - by Lucas Cranach
the Elder (1529)
Hessisches Landesmuseum
Darmstadt
Luther's 1534
Bible
Luther's "Ein Feste Burg"
("A Mighty Fortress")
One of only very few early
printings of Luther's hymn. There are no known first edition printings
left.
This book is a second edition,
and extremely rare.
The Lutherhaus Museum - Wittenberg
|
Emperor Charles V tries to suppress Luther
The
newly elected Holy Roman Emperor, Charles V of Hababurg now took up the
issue on the side of the Roman church. Luther, now excommunicated but
still under the protection of Frederick and widely popular in Germany,
was called by the Emperor to an Imperial Council (Diet) at Worms in
1521 to give account of his views. Here Luther stood firm in his
views against the Roman church.And under an Imperial guarantee of his
freedom, Luther was able to get away from the Council before the
guarantee was retracted.
From then on for the rest of his life, Luther remained in seclusion in
Frederick's Wartburg Castle, translating the Bible into German ... and
publishing numerous works denouncing in vivid language the leadership
and practices of the Roman church. These writings spread rapidly
(thanks in part to the new printing press) throughout Europe – until
talk of Luther and his challenges to the Church (and thus Christendom)
was under discussion everywhere.
In the meanwhile the Emperor found himself preoccupied by an on-going
war with France over control of various cities and principalities in
Italy. Then the Turkish threat to the Emperor's Austrian holdings rose
again. Thus the Emperor was seriously distracted in his effort to quiet
Luther. Luther was relatively safe.
|

Charles of Habsburg - Holy
Roman Emperor (Charles V) and King of Spain (Charles I)
- by Rubens
|
The Peasant War of 1524-1525
But
when German commoners took his challenges as an invitation to rise up
against the burden of all of Christendom's traditional authority, civil
as well as religious, Luther came out passionately against the revolt.
Indeed, Luther was no revolutionary .. only a reformer. For
Luther his call for religious reform was related to the matter of a
sinner's personal justification before God. Luther showed little
interest in making broader changes within Christianity beyond the
throwing off of Roman spiritual authority – with its traditions of
works-righteousness. Substantial changes in worship, for
instance, were of lesser interest to Luther. Also the episcopal
or hierarchical form of church government (rule "from above" by
bishops) was not itself questioned by Luther – although he did strongly
support the idea that the bishops were answerable to the local
princes ... not to Rome.
This it proved to be the case that he stood strongly on the side of the
princes against the German rebels (Müntzer and the "Zwickau
prophets") who took up the political cause of the German commoner
against their rulers. In the course of this peasant rebellion, Luther
came down harshly against the peasant rebels, denouncing them in the
same strong language that he used to denounce the hierarchy of the
Roman Church.2
The peasants and their leaders were put down cruelly by the local
princes and their mercenary troops (6,000 peasants lost their lives
alone in the one-day battle of Frankenhausen).
The result of the Peasant War was to move real power over to the
various German princes. Thus in Germany, the rule of the church was not
a matter either of local congregational power – nor of the power of
popes and bishops. Rather, it was the ruling prince in each of
the many principalities that made up Germany who determined each in his
own territory its particular Christian character. Some remained loyal
to Rome (the southern German princes). Some followed the Lutheran
line (the northern German princes) with their new Schmalkaldic League,
a powerful political alliance which was dedicated, among other things,
to backing Luther in every way possible. But in any case it was the
local princes who made that determination. The dependence of
church on state was thus set as the characteristic feature of German
Christianity.
Thus
in the end, although he was willing to break from the feudal Church,
Luther was not willing to break from the feudal civil government in
Northern Germany. Consequently, Luther's reforms would go only
part-way in bringing Germany out of its medieval background ... and
leave it still with a feudal social system, one that would last all the
way up into the early 20th century. Furthermore, because Luther's
religious movement was constructed deeply on these social foundations
of a rather permanently medieval (rural) north-central Europe,
"Lutheranism" would have almost no impact on any of Europe's rapidly
developing industrial (urban) areas.
Thomas Müntzer (c. 1490-1525)
Müntzer was the active leader of the unsuccessful Peasants' Revolt in
Thuringia (1524-1525) that so upset Luther. Müntzer took a
mystical view about the humble classes being the true repository of
God's Spirit and the proper instrument of God's transformative work on
earth. His theological writings and personal leadership were of
major importance in motivating the peasants' revolt against the German
ruling classes. At the Battle of Frankenhausen in May of 1525 his
peasant forces were defeated – and Müntzer was taken prisoner and
executed.
2In his Wider die Mordischen und Reubischen Rotten der Bawren
[Against the Robbing Murderous Hordes of Peasants] (1525) he advises
the German princes to take necessary action against the peasants: "Let
everyone who can, smite, slay and stab, secretly and publicly, . . . a
poisonous, devilish rebel, like one must kill a rabid dog."
The Battle of Frankenhausen - May 15, 1525

Thomas Müntzer - Leader
of the Peasant Rebellion
An 18th century engraving
by C. Van Sichem. No contemporary image of the reformer exists.
Andreas Bodenstein von
Karlstadt
A theological scholar who
supported deeper social-political reforms than Luther
ZWINGLI AND
THE EMERGENCE OF SWISS REFORM (1520s) |
|
Ulrich Zwingli (1484-1531)
 As
a young man, Zwingli he received a humanistic university education in
Vienna and Basel. As a parish priest he continued his studies in
Greek and Hebrew and of the humanist Erasmus and the classics. In
1518 he was brought to Zurich, Switzerland, as its pastor … where he
gained reputation as a brilliant preacher and scholar.
It was here that his inquiring mind also began to draw him toward
Luther's reform movement. In 1522 Zwingli began to make his own
moves to establish Scripture as the sole religious authority for the
Christian. He opposed the Lenten Fast, citing the lack of
Scriptural warrant for the practice – a position which was supported by
the Zurich civil government. The bishop of Constance tried to
suppress this innovation, but lost out to the Zurich government, which
moved to take control of ecclesiastical matters within its
jurisdiction. Zwingli supported this shift in authority, claiming
that the civil government, under the Lordship of Christ and guided in
its work by the dictates of Scripture, was the sole legitimate voice or
conscience of the believing community.
He also moved to reform various features of worship, whenever there was
no specific Scriptural warrant for such things, though he did so
through a practice of gradualism. By 1525, however, he had
eliminated statues and relics from the Zurich church, eliminated the
Latin mass (substituting a memorial celebration of the Lord's Supper in
its place) and placed at the heart of worship the sermon (a rather
extensive exposition of Scripture) – the key feature of the Swiss
Reformation.
But the conservative rural cantons of Switzerland remained firmly
opposed to the Zwinglian reforms. Relations grew bitter and
hostilities resulted – with Zwingli himself being wounded and then put
to death in a losing battle with the rural cantons in 1531.
The more gentle-natured Heinrich Bullinger then took over the Zurich reform movement.
The Split within the Protestant Ranks
Meanwhile, the reform movement was beginning to move in different and
opposing theological directions. To Zwingli and the Swiss
reformers (identified as the Reformed party) there were strong
interests in restructuring the organization and practices of the church
around its original constitutional base: Scripture. There was a
stripping away of every feature of Christianity that could not be
supported by Scriptural warrant. This was in keeping with
Zwingli's humanist background – and its focus on the Greek and Hebrew
origins of the church, and the sense that everything that was a
departure from this classical age was a perversion of an original
purity undergirding the church.
This would not probably have kept Luther and Zwingli from working
closely together – except that one portion of Zwingli's reforms were
violently opposed by Luther: Zwingli's treatment of the
celebration of the Lord's supper. Zwingli (for whom the sermon,
not the celebration of the eucharist, was the central point of
Christian worship) interpreted Christ's words concerning his presence
in the wine and bread as purely symbolic. To Luther, this was a
shocking diminution of the power of the real presence of Christ in the
elements of the eucharist. The gap was, in both their minds,
unbridgeable by the mid 1520s. Others of both parties tried to effect a
compromise. But Luther, even after Zwingli's death, would not
hear of compromise. Lutheranism and the Reformed faith split
permanently.
But Zwingli's legacy lived on … taken up importantly by Johannes
Oecolampadius in Basel. But it spread as well to Bern and
Constance … and ultimately Geneva. And this Reform Movement also
made its way down the Rhine River to Strasbourg – where under the
leadership of Martin Bucer – who tried to unite the Lutheran and
Zwinglian Reform Movements (but Luther was not supportive of the
effort) – the Reform Movement took on the more thoroughgoing Swiss
character (as distinct from the more conservative Lutheran variety).
|
The Religious Colloquium
of Marburg of 1529 - anonymous - wood carving (1557). By invitation
of the Landgrave
Philipp of Hesse, Luther and Zwingli came to Marburg
in September of
1529.
They were accompanied by
some of their followers, Melanchthon
being among these.
They were to settle their
dispute about communion.
But in this key matter they were not successful.
|
But it would be John Calvin in Geneva that would bring the Swiss Reform Movement to full power.
Calvin was a Frenchman, schooled in the new humanist tradition … and
prepared at the universities of Orléans and Bourges to be a lawyer. He
fell in with a circle of French humanists who read with great interest
the writings of Luther. Then, somewhere in the period 1532-1534 Calvin
experienced a "sudden conversion" (the details of which unfortunately
he never discussed publicly.) From this point on his
well-organized mind was given over to theology rather than the
law. At the same time his theological associations became very
dangerous to an increasingly suspicious French king, Francis I.
In 1536, Calvin felt compelled to write, with all respect to his
monarch, a reply to Francis' suspicions about the "protestants": The Institutes of the Christian Religion.3
It was Calvin's hope that Francis, through this long essay, would come
to understand that the protestants posed no threat to his rule – but
only sought to revitalize the original Christian ideal on which the
whole Christian realm ought to be properly based. Though it was
the most compelling theological treatise explaining the protestant
position – it did not have its intended effect of swaying the views of
Francis. Instead, it identified Calvin as a voice of religious
dissent, not tolerated in France. Calvin was thus forced to flee
France. He intended to relocate to Strasbourg, where the reform movement was well underway.
His path there took him to Geneva (Switzerland) ... where the
Protestant reformer William Farel prevailed upon Calvin not to head on
to Strasbourg but to stay in the city and help him strengthen the Swiss
Reformed Movement which was growing rapidly there. Calvin
agreed. But for Calvin, this proved to be a stormy
decision. Geneva was an unruly city, and Calvin's natural bent
toward orderliness and discipline quickly made him many enemies in the
city. In the spring of 1538 Calvin and Farel were banished from
Geneva. Calvin headed on to Strasbourg, where, by that time, the
"Reformed" movement was well established.
But in 1541, the old group of Calvin's supporters in Geneva urgently
requested his return to the city. Calvin somewhat reluctantly
decided to go back to Geneva – but on his terms. Upon his return,
Calvin organized (accepting many compromises with the city Council) the
religious life of the city around his new Ordinances – the foundation
of Reformed polity. Geneva in turn became identified under
Calvin's leadership as the model Christian city, the "New Jerusalem" of
Protestantism.
Calvin's reforms help develop a strong European "Middle Class"
Calvin was an urban European,
steeped in the bourgeois mindset of the rising European urban "middle
class." Calvin's interest in reform of the crumbling medieval
moral legal order involved importantly a vision of the new urban order
as central to a purified Christianity. Thus his interest in
reform did not limit itself merely to matters of religious doctrine –
as was the case for Luther. Calvin truly was interested in a
comprehensive reordering of every aspect of post medieval life:
political, economic, and social as well as theological.
Importantly, he gave a theological rationale for the independent
mindedness of the urban commercial class – arming them with Scriptural
justification for going their own way within God's creation.
Indeed, he encouraged them to establish purified political economic
social orders as a way of purging Christendom of its corruption and of
bringing glory to God in Jesus Christ. He made their soul
searching independent mindedness a matter of the greatest importance in
their standing before God. They not only had the right to be
accountable to God alone as sovereign over them – they had the
Christian duty to see that this was the case. The supposition was
that any earthly lord who positioned himself between them and God was
going to be problematic in their "purified" relationship with God and
their covenantal life in the purified Christian commonwealth.
Certainly the followers of Calvin attempted to convince the rich and
powerful kings of Europe that their movement had no treasonous
instincts – and that they planned to be good citizens in the realms
where they lived. The kings were not convinced. And rightly
so. Everything about Calvinism pointed to the idea of these
people being accountable to no earthly ruler but to God alone.
Switzerland, which was the birthplace of Calvin's Reformed Movement was
well recognized for its independent-mindedness and refusal to
acknowledge the rule of any princely lord over the land. No ...
Calvin's Reformed Movement, or "Calvinism" was destined to bring a
clash with traditional princely and priestly rulers who claimed to rule
by "divine rights." That was exactly what the Calvinists claimed
for their own "self-rule": the common people's own self-rule by
divine right – even by divine imperative. There was no way
these two mind-sets were going to work cooperatively.
The extensive spread of Calvinism to urban Europe
It
was not long before word spread widely of what was happening in Geneva
under Calvin's reforms. Thus it was that during the second half
of the 1500s, individuals from all corners of Europe came to Geneva to
be a part of this new Reformed Movement. There they learned of
ways to rebuild their communities as "covenant" communities …
covenanted with God to live solely by Scriptural standards. And
there in Geneva they busied themselves also in translating and
publishing exactly those scriptural standards (the Bible) in the
various languages spoken across the European continent.
And thus it was that "Calvinism" came to be well-planted in the towns
and cities of England (the Puritans), Scotland and Northern Ireland
(the Presbyterians), Netherlands (the Dutch Reformed), France (the
Huguenots), Western Germany, Bohemia and Hungary (the German, Czech and
Hungarian Reformed Movement) – and even parts of Poland and Spain,
where it later got eradicated by the Catholic Counter-Reformation
overseen by the Catholic popes and Habsburg emperors.
The Michael Servetus affair
Theologically, the times were very intense ... as we have just seen in
Luther's reaction to the peasant revolt in Germany. But the
intensity of the times does not offer much of an excuse as to Calvin's
behavior in the face of a bitter theological attack on him (just
words!) offered by a highly self-important Spanish intellectual (and
accomplished medical doctor), who took delight in accusing Calvin of
the evil of Trinitarianism, which – according to Servetus' book Errors of the Trinity (1531) – was nothing more than a grand deception of the devil ... and those who held to it, servants of the devil.
Furthermore, Servetus presented himself (in his book The Restitution of Christianity)
as the Michael of Scripture (from Revelation and Daniel) who was called
to fight the antichrist, in order to usher in the End Times.
Calvin got involved with Servetus back in 1546, when Servetus sent Calvin a copy of The Restitution of Christianity
... resulting in a correspondence between the two men which started out
calmly enough, but which quickly grew increasingly bitter as
accusations and counter-accusations intensified. Calvin thus
stopped the correspondence ... totally embittered by Servetus.
But Servetus went on, announcing abroad that not only was Calvin the
imposter Simon Magus, but both Calvin and the Pope were antichrists,
needing to be dismissed in order to restore Christianity to its
original character.
Servetus eventually got himself condemned by French authorities for his
supposed Unitarianism ... escaped imprisonment, and decided to head to
Italy for refuge. But strangely, he stopped by Geneva (1553) and
decided to attend a worship service conducted by Calvin – when he was
spotted and arrested. Servetus was duly tried and convicted of
heresy ... and sentenced to be burned at the stake. Calvin tried
to soften the sentence somewhat by calling for a beheading ... but
could not get the Council to back down. Calvin and his friend
Farel also visited Servetus in prison to get Servetus to recant of his
Unitarian beliefs. But Servetus would not recant. And thus
the sentence was carried out.
To this day it is debated as to whether Calvin could not have exerted
more pressure – for instance, to have Servetus banished rather than
executed. But Calvin at the time was having his own political
difficulties with the town council over matters of town governance
governance … and seemingly needed to appear to be no less strong than
the council in the (typical) handling of heretics.
In any case, it is another example of how frequently Christian
theological precision gets way ahead of the Gospel of Jesus
Christ. And it certainly was not the first time, nor certainly
also the last. In fact, in those days a lot of this sort of thing
would be going on ... doing the West's Christian foundations a huge
disservice ... not to mention a huge disservice to Jesus Christ.
3This
work underwent numerous editions, increasing in coverage with each new
issue, from a single volume of six chapters in 1536 ultimately by 1559
to four volumes of 80 chapters, indicative of his own development as a
scholar-teacher.
A young John Calvin - Flemish
school (Unknown) (Oil on wood panel) 1500s
Société du Musée Historique
de la Réformation, Bibliothèque de Genève
Institutio Christianae
religionis (Institutes of Christian religion). Geneva: Robert Estienne,
1559
This is the definitive and
fourth edition of Calvin's compendium of reformed theology; the first edition
was published in 1536
Portrait of John Calvin -
anonymous - 1500s
Bibliothèque de
Genève
Portrait of John Calvin -
Titian (Tiziano Vecellio) - 1500s
The Reformed Church of France,
Paris, France
Portrait of John Calvin at
fifty-three years old - 1562 - by René Boyvin
Bibliothèque de
Genève
 Calvin preaching in Geneva
Guillaume (William) Farel
(1580)
original portrait in Theodore
Beza's Icones
Unitarian Michael Servetus
(Miguel Servet) - by Christian Fritzsch
Spanish scientist and theologian
of the Renaissance. Burned at the stake in Geneva in 1553.
Martin Bucer (1560) - by
Jean Jacques Boissard
original in Icones quinquaginta
vivorum held in British Library, London
Another reformer in trouble: William Tyndale strangled and then burned at a stake in Belgium for daring to translate the Hebrew and Greek texts of the Bible into English - 1536
He
did so to update Wycliff's English version which used an older "Middle
English" not easily understandable by the early 1500s.
Much of the Geneva Bible, published 20 years later (1557) and popular
among the Puritans, was derived from Tyndale's work ... although
Tyndale had not completed his translation of the Old Testament
before he was put to death. The Geneva Bible would finish
the task.
Also ...King James's English translation in the early 1600s would draw heavily from Tyndale's English translation.
SCOTLAND ...
UNDER KNOX'S "PRESBYTERIAN" REFORMS |
 We
must at this point mention one of these "Calvinists": John Knox,
the great Protestant reformer of Scotland. Knox not only helped
direct Scotland to Calvinist Protestantism in the mid 1500s, but also
left a powerful political legacy within the Calvinist or Reformed
branch of Protestantism, a political legacy we call
"Presbyterianism." Knox's Presbyterianism not only deternimed the
organization of the Church of Scotland but also layed the foundations
for the growth of representative democracy in the American middle
colonies (from New Jersey to South Carolina) in the 1600s and 1700s.
As with many Protestant reformers, Knox began as a Catholic priest,
highly discontent with the moral and spiritual corruption that had
overtaken the Mother Church. He was attracted to the Lutheran
teachings of the early Scottish reformer, George Wishart; was appalled
when in 1546 the Catholic cardinal had Wishart burned at the stake as a
heretic; and then joined the group of rebels who moved to overthrow the
hand of the Catholic church over Scotland. This put him in
opposition to the pro-French party that ruled Scotland – and when
French troops in 1547 crushed this Protestant rebellion in Scotland,
Knox was led off to captivity as a French galley slave. His
release was finally secured by the pro-Protestant English King Edward
VI, leading Knox to come to England to be a Protestant pastor and then
chaplain to the King
But when Edward died in 1553 and Catholic Mary Tudor ("Bloody Mary")
came to the throne, Knox left England and made his way eventually to
Geneva Switzerland where he joined a community of English expatriates
living and studying under the direction of the great Genevan reformer,
John Calvin. Knox took a great liking to both Calvin and his
teachings and subsequently became a major voice in the English/Scottish
reform movement not only in Geneva, but through letters, to a growing
Protestant movement back in Scotland.
He
returned briefly to Scotland in 1555, then back to Geneva to become
pastor of the English church there ... and then finally in 1559 he
returned definitively to Scotland to take over the spiritual leadership
of the Protestant rebellion against the French-Catholic regent of
Scotland, Mary of Guise.
Seeing that things were not going well in Scotland for the Protestant
party, Queen Elizabeth of England came to their aid against the French
in Scotland. But when Mary of Guise died suddenly in 1560, the
French Catholic cause in Scotland was dead. Scotland was now won
for Protestantism.
At this point Knox and his supporters began to reshape the Scottish
church – not only theologically along the lines of Calvin's Reformed
Faith born in Geneva, but also politically in a way that was Knox's
special contribution to the Protestant cause. Knox took the idea
of representative government characteristic of Calvin's reformed
churches (communities lead by elected elders or "presbyters"), and
applied it locally, regionally and nationally in total reversal of the
top-down or hierarchical fashion of Catholic or "episcopalian"
government. Thus local councils ("Presbyteries"), regional
councils ("Synods") and national councils ("General Assemblies") that
presided over the faithful were made up of representatives not of the
political rulers over the church but of the people themselves.
Thus was born "Presbyterian" or representative church government – the
source of inspiration for the new Democratic or Republican forms of
government that led eventually to the Constitution of 1789 underpinning
the new American Republic.
Despite success in the Protestant takeover of the church Scotland, the
continuing existence of a Catholic monarchy in Scotland under Mary of
Guise's daughter, Mary Queen of Scots, made life still highly
problematic for Protestant Scotland – and for John Knox personally as
the two locked wills in on-going battle. But
eventually Mary's political blunders forced her to flee to England,
where Elizabeth put her under house arrest ... and eventualy had her
put to death.
In any case Knox, worn out and sickly, died from his labors in
1572. But his work in Scotland was carried forth faithfully
by others, notably Andrew Melville.
For more on Knox
|

John Knox
Mary of Guise - Queen consort
of Scotland
mother of Mary I and regent
of Scotland - 1554-1560
(member of the House of
Guise, leaders of the fiercely anti-Protestant Roman Catholic Party in
France) Hatfield House
A young Mary I Stuart - Queen of
Scots by school of François Clouet - 1560-1561
She reigned 1554 - 1567 (forced to
abdicate in 1567 in favor of her one-year-old son, James ... future King of both Scotland and England)
Hatfield House
THE CATHOLIC
COUNTER-REFORMATION |
The
papal party finally realized the seriousness of the challenge to its
moral authority – and in 1546 called a Council at Trent to answer the
Protestant charges of ecclesiastical corruption and theological
deviation. Rigid discipline was re-imposed over the priests who
remained loyal to Rome. Luther's teaching on divine grace and
justification alone by faith was condemned. A campaign was readied to
wipe out any "heretics" not ready to return to Roman discipline. The
war was thus on.
The Roman church, championed by the most powerful ruling family
in Europe (the Spanish Habsburgs) – well-financed from their plunder of
South and Central America – fought back cruelly, trying to stamp out
the fires of the Protestant revolt. They succeeded in many places – and
might have been fully successful had not the Muslim Turks attacked
Vienna – the Eastern center of Habsburg power--during the height of
this struggle. With the Habsburgs thus distracted, Protestantism dug in.
Pope Paul III and the Council of Trent
Pope Paul, under some
considerable pressure by Spanish king Charles I, called the Council of
Mantua (1537) to begin dealing with some of the issues of the
reformation. But that Council got disrupted by a new round of
warfare between Francis I of France and Charles. In 1542 Paul
again called a Council, this time located at Trent (Austria) – thought
it did not begin deliberations until the end of 1545.
At the same time, Paul established the Supreme Tribunal of the
Inquisition – a remake of the old Papal Inquisition which in the
previous century had largely been suspended in its operations.
The revival of the Inquisition in Spain under the Spanish monk Thomas
de Torquemada – who for 18 years used its techniques of torture in a
very "successful" manner against Muslims, Jews and Christian heretics –
no doubt persuaded Paul of its constructive use in stamping out
heresy. But political realities kept Paul's wonderful scheme
limited to Italy – where it did a masterful job of discouraging
Protestantism among the Italians (as the Spanish Inquisition did in
Spain).
Paul's Council of Trent continued its meetings after his death in 1549,
though he had by then clearly laid out the lines it would take.
The Council of Trent met until 1552 (though it had to move to Bologna
from 1547 to 1551 to escape an epidemic). After 1552 it did
not meet again until 1562 and completed its work the following year.
At the Council (as in his life) Paul took a very reactive position in
the matter of the need for reforming the church. To him it was a
straightforward matter of organizing the powers of the church to stamp
out the Protestant heresy.
But Charles was deeply desirous of reform in the church in order to
steal the ideological advantage the Protestants enjoyed over a number
of issues dividing the church. Charles wanted the church to tighten up
its moral laxness and make significant compromises in matters of
doctrine pressed by the Protestants – in order to restore unity within
Christendom.
But Paul held the line against anything that looked like a concession
to the Protestants. Thus the Council of Trent, under his
leadership, moved to anathematize (condemn) the Protestant position and
to reaffirm the church's position that Tradition stood as a coequal
with Scripture in determining church issues and doctrines.
The Latin Vulgate was
pronounced the only authoritative version of the Bible. No
translations into the languages of the day would be allowed.
Further, no copies of even the Latin Vulgate were to be printed or
distributed without authorization from church authorities.
Also, the Council reaffirmed the doctrine that faith and works jointly
formed the path to salvation – and not faith alone, which was a central
Protestant position on the subject of salvation.
Latin was to continue to be the language of the mass, the cup was to
continue to be withheld from the laity during the sacrament of Holy
communion, celibacy was to continue to be the order for the clergy –
and a number of other doctrinal matters would remain unchanged.
There were no doctrinal concessions to be made to the Protestants.
However the Council did move to tighten moral discipline in the church
– a major Catholic embarrassment in the dispute with the
Protestants. Clerical appointments were to be scrutinized more
closely for moral-spiritual justification. Education of the
clergy was to be stressed. And the preaching skills of the clergy
were to be improved.
Overall, the tightening up of Catholic doctrine made the church look
much less confused in the face of Protestant challenges. And the
new moral regimen removed the matters that were the most obvious source
of popular discontent against the church among the people (most
doctrinal issues escaped popular understanding anyway).
Indeed, Pope Paul and the Council of Trent gave the Catholic Church a new crusading spirit against the Protestant "heresy."
|

Pope Paul III - who
convened the Council of Trent - painting by Titian
Naples, Galleria Nazionale
di Capodimonte
The Council of Trent - by
Cati da Iesi
(with allegorical figures
representing various virtues including "The Church Triumphant")
|
The Jesuits (Society of Jesus)
In
1540, Pope Paul III authorized Ignatius of Loyola and six companions to
form a new priestly order, the Society of Jesus. Unsurprisingly,
given Loyola's own background as a nobleman-soldier, the new order took
on the character of a military unit, tightly disciplined to undertake
very challenging work, as ordered by the Superior General (Ignatius
initially) … himself under the personal command of the pope. They
were to serve the papacy as frontline missionaries, "soldiers of God,"
taking Catholicism to all parts of the world – from Canada to Paraguay,
to Ethiopia, to Japan, and everything in between! In Christian
Europe itself, they would serve principally as teachers of classical
theology, rhetoric, mathematics, even music! – most notably to the
youth of Europe's ruling class. And as evangelists, they
dedicated themselves to countering the evangelism being undertaken by
the Protestants. |
The Founding of the Jesuits
(Society of Jesus) by Ignatius of Loyola
Ignatius of Loyola (1491-1556)
- founder of the Jesuits - by Peter Paul Rubens (ealy 1600s)


Go on to the next section: The Development of the Dynastic State
Miles
H. Hodges
| |
|